Book Review: Rethinking the Great White North
By Dr. Randolph Haluza-DeLay
It is unusual for an academic book to be attacked by a newspaper columnist. But that happened to a recent book called Rethinking the Great White North. Remembering Pierre Bertonâs line that having sex in a canoe is what makes one Canadian, The Globe & Mailâs Margaret Wente had suggested that maybe new immigrants should be taught to canoe – so they could be more like real Canadians.
The editors of Rethinking the Great White North took her to. The perception that âCanada = Canoeingâ they said, was just one of the ways a European colonial mentality permeates both our sense of nation and our sense of nature. Wente lashed back in the pages of The Globe & Mail. Yet nature reflects race â read the book!
When I came to Canada as an immigrant, I quickly learned how much the North matters to the Canadian imagination. Nature and the boreal forest are also huge parts of the typical history and sense of identity for the country. But I first lived in northern Saskatchewan and quickly learned there isnât one âCanadianâ way of thinking about the land and often these ways of thinking split on ethnic lines. This book clearly shows how race and nature intermingle.
For example, that view of the North as wilderness is a way of thinking that often absents native peoples. The national narrative refers to, and then brushes over, the native present/presence. It is part of why the oil sands development proceeds as rapaciously as it does â âthereâs [sort of] no one thereâ they say, and Canadians believe it, so can sacrifice the empty land.
For Christians, there is no way that creation can be seen as simply raw material for industrialization. It is a âgift of good landâ as Wendell Berry put it. The Earth is the Lordâs (Psalm 24), and we are tenants. But even thinking about property ownership of land (or water, see http://parklandinstitute.ca/media/comments/new_report_says_markets_are_a_poor_solution_to_albertas_water_woes/) is a Eurocentric approach. Christians are heavily influenced by the cultures in which we live.
Rethinking the Great White North is an academic book with some of the complicated language that make people avoid reading such books. But that would be a mistake. An even worse mistake would be to ignore the entwining of race, nature, ethnicity and colonization that still permeate Canadian society. We need to trouble the narratives of nature too often used in environmental action.
Baldwin, Andrew, Laura Cameron, and Audrey Kobayashi, eds. 2011. Rethinking the great white north: Race, nature and the historical geographies of whiteness in Canada. Vancouver: UBC Press. Paperback: $37.95. ISBN 9780774820141.
Posted: January 20th, 2012 under Book Review, Haluza-DeLay, King's Faculty.
Tags: Canada, geography, immigration
Comments: none

